A Research Comparison of Western and Non-Western Healing Arts

Alusine M. Kanu, D.A. 

Western healing arts can be in contrast and contrasted with non-western healing arts. This short article identifies the western healing art of multicultural counseling in comparison to non-western healing arts. Research has indicated the Western ideology is embedded in the techniques of counseling and improvement (Daniels, 2007). Western counseling is oriented largely toward helping individuals enable by themselves so they can correctly function by adapting to their environmental contexts. Western ideology emphasizes the rational above the relational, the reasonable above the psychological, levels of competition above cooperation, and independence above interdependence.

 Western ideology is primarily based on individualism, which typically leads to self-focused actions. The goal of western counseling is the strengthening of the self, identity, or ego. The philosophy guiding Chinese medicine is a melding of tenets from Buddhism, Confucianism, and the mixed spiritual and philosophical ideas of Taoism. Even though there are numerous educational facilities of assumed between practitioners of regular Chinese medicine, five Taoist axioms form its foundation. There are normal laws which govern the universe, including human beings. The normal purchase of the universe is innately harmonious and very well arranged. When men and women dwell according to the laws of the universe, they dwell in harmony with that universe and the normal atmosphere. The universe is dynamic, with modify as it can be only continual. Stagnation is in opposition to the law of the universe and results in what Western medicine calls ailment. All residing issues are related and interdependent. Individuals are intimately related to and affected by all sides of their atmosphere. The broader conceptual framework on multicultural counseling competencies is primarily based on the Affiliation for Multicultural Counseling and Improvement as described in Multicultural Counseling Competencies (Roysircar et al., 2003). The model emphasizes a practitioner’s awareness of cultural values, beliefs, and biases in purchase to be informed of the client’s planet see and provide culturally proper treatment.

 J.D. Kinzie (1990), evaluating primary western values with Asian values, illustrates areas of variation in between western and non-western healing. It demonstrates that Indochinese individual values focus on interdependence, and western practitioners feel in private option and independence. Chinese have structured and proper social relationships, while Westerners feel in situational ethics, challenge for authorities, and equality of relatives relationships. Chinese healing thinks one particular must dwell in harmony with character, and Westerners feel character is to be mastered. Chinese feel that mental ailment is caused by imbalance in cosmic forces or deficiency of will energy. Westerners feel that mental ailment is a consequence of mental and bodily components. Indochinese individual values are that treatment must be short and quick. Westerners feel therapy could acquire a extended time. Easterners feel the healer must be lively and give options to problems. Westerners see the therapist as typically passive, and the most effective option is one particular produced by the individual.

 Another main variation is how the individual is regarded. In western medicine, sufferers with comparable issues or ailments normally will receive pretty much the exact treatment. In regular Chinese medicine, the doctor treats the individual, and not the affliction, believing that similar ailments can have entirely various results in. In conditions of the concepts on which it is primarily based and the procedures utilised, regular Chinese medicine is deemed by several in the west to be a radically various technique. At the main of western counseling therapy lie emotions: validating, uncovering, processing, accepting and expressing emotions. Whatsoever else is associated in healing, Westerners feel that knowing their emotions improved leads to greater psychological health and fitness. Chinese usually acquire the opposite see: controlling one’s psychological expression is needed for psychological health and fitness instead they emphasize good perform and silent reserve. Consequently a Chinese counselee will regularly give short responses and converse only when questioned by the counselor. Also, Asians are more snug with silence than Westerners. Westerners usually see a pause of a few seconds in a conver-sation as an invitation to chat. Asians typically pause a lot for a longer period in between responses.

Classic Chinese medicine is an ancient and continue to very important holistic technique of health and fitness and healing, primarily based on the idea of harmony and stability and using the ideas of moderation and prevention. In idea and follow, regular Chinese medicine is entirely various from western medicine, each in conditions of looking at how the human entire body operates and how ailment takes place and must be treated. In regular Chinese medicine, each philosophically and medically, moderation in all issues is advocated, as is residing in harmony with character and striving for stability in all issues. Avoidance is also a crucial goal of Chinese medicine, and a lot emphasis is positioned on educating the individual to dwell responsibly.

 The main variation in between regular counseling and multicultural counseling is that a primary basic principle of multicultural counseling emphasizes knowing clients from their sociocultural contexts (e.g., race, gender, class, sexual orientation, incapacity, age, faith, language and faith). Without looking at sociocultural contexts, it is difficult to study consequences of class on the entire man or woman. Conversation models also differ in between western and non-western cultures. Westerners favor immediate interaction. On the other hand, Chinese tradition sees these com-munication as confrontational, especially to one particular in a culturally superior placement. Subtlety and indirect enable is considerably prized in Asian cultures. Also, Chinese clients will seldom complain openly that they are dissatisfied with therapy they simply will not return.

The similarity in between Chinese and Western healing techniques is the growing improvement of exploration. Hou, Bai, et al. (2008) identified typical topics covered by counseling linked journals in Western cultures, including counseling interventions outcomes, counseling outcomes, counseling interventions in association with other treatments (e.g., medicine), ethical difficulties, counseling methods and programs, counseling procedures, counselor qualification and qualified improvement and surveys on the position of counseling. The improvement of indigenous counseling in Chinese communities may incorporate exploration that examines the utility of adapting contexts, as very well as discovering functions of assorted client populations, instruction and credentialing of counseling specialists and interventions that include indigenous techniques into treatment (Blowers, 1996). As the counseling occupation in China progresses and matures, it would be useful for specialists to play a more lively position in numerous forms of collaboration, as they must enrich the world counseling local community through synthesizing Eastern and Western cultural values into their exploration and follow operate (Leung, 2003). Another healing follow is that the Chinese code of ethics is seriously affected by current ethical codes in the Western planet.

 Another similarity in between Western and non-western healing techniques is the realization of the potential advantages of counseling. Optimistic contacts in between East and West impact deeper exploration of cultures. Another advantage is creating have confidence in, mutual advantage and appreciative partnership. Interactions by each cultures enhance cultural competencies and studying by experiencing, dilemma solving methods with bridging roles for modify and growing institutional assistance. Collaboration, therefore, integrates Western and Eastern cultures. Assessments of health and fitness and healing techniques are worthy of thought in examining and evaluating Western and non-western techniques. The scientific process is a method of validating healing procedures and is an powerful mode of treatment intervention. It follows that some non-western healing procedures ought to be validated by stringent exploration ahead of they can be reliably built-in into regular Western follow. The application of the scientific process to evaluate recent or most effective proof is a practical follow to evaluate by a systematic method. The crucial method of proof primarily based on exploration rests on the reliability of the method of exploration methodology, layout and info assessment. Basic exploration demonstrates usefulness on the functional and contextual integration of follow.

 M. Javier (2007) suggests most effective techniques in intercultural health and fitness treatment desires to fulfill conditions which incorporate having a good affect on the individuals and populace served, sustainable, currently being responsive and related to individual and local community health and fitness desires to cultural and environmental realities, currently being client-focused, enhancing access, coor-dinating and integrating products and services, currently being effective and adaptable, demonstrating management and currently being revolutionary, showing potential for replication, figuring out health and fitness and coverage desires and having a capacity for evaluation. There is a great have to have to acknowledge and embrace the various forms of counseling around the planet. Examining the cultural values and techniques of people in assorted nations around the world can direct not only to a improved knowing of these nations around the world, but also a richer perspective about one’s very own tradition and numerous methods to counseling. There is a great deal of potential for multicultural and cross-countrywide actions in counseling to enrich one particular another. A concerted collaboration can improve the sophistication of counseling exploration planet large, extend the complexities of recent know-how and theoretical products, enhance the vary of counseling interventions, and in essence, improve counseling usefulness across a vary of populations in Western and Eastern healing techniques and outside of.


 Blowers, G. H. (1996). “The potential clients for a Chinese psychology in M. H. Bond (ed.), Handbook of Chinese Psychology (pp. one-fourteen). Hong Kong, SAR, China: Oxford University Press.

 Daniels, J. (2007). “The Fourth Force in Counseling and Remedy: Multicultural and Feminist Perspectives,” in Ivey et al. Theories of Counseling and Psychotherapy: A Multicultural Viewpoint, (sixth ed.), pp. 319-358. Boston: Pearson Education.

 Hou, Z. J., Bai (2008). A ten-calendar year articles assessment of posts on counseling and psychotherapy printed in the Chinese Psychological Wellness Journal. Peoples Republic of China: Beijing Ordinary University.

 Javier, M. et al. (2007). “Best techniques in intercultural health and fitness,” Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine. three: p. 31.

 Kinzie, J. D. (1990). “Overview of clinical difficulties in the treatment of Southeast Asian Refugees,” in T. C. Owan (ed.) Southeast Asian Psychological Wellness Remedy, Avoidance Providers, Schooling and Research, Washington DC: Countrywide Institute of Psychological Wellness, n.d.: p. 311.

 Leung, S.A. (2003). “The journal well worth traveling: Globalization of counseling psychology,” The Counseling Psychologist, 31, pp. 412-419.

 Roysircar et al (2003). Multicultural Counseling Competencies. Alexandria VA: Affiliation of Multicultural Counseling and Improvement.